| Club | League | Years |
|---|---|---|
| Aston Villa | Premier League | 1972–1979 |
| Everton | Premier League | 1979–1981 |
| Manchester United | Premier League | 1981–1986 |
| Manchester City | Premier League | 1986–1988 |
| Stoke City | Premier League | 1988–1989 |
| Liverpool | Premier League | — |
Only the clubs in the game are in the data; spells at other clubs, loans and youth years may be missing.
Which club pairs is John Gidman an answer for?
In Who Played Both, if two of these clubs meet, John Gidman is one of the right answers.
- Manchester City – Manchester United 59 players
- Everton – Manchester City 54 players
- Manchester City – Stoke City 53 players
- Aston Villa – Everton 49 players
- Aston Villa – Manchester United 47 players
- Aston Villa – Stoke City 47 players
- Everton – Manchester United 46 players
- Everton – Liverpool 46 players
- Everton – Stoke City 39 players
- Aston Villa – Liverpool 37 players
- Liverpool – Manchester City 37 players
- Aston Villa – Manchester City 36 players
- Liverpool – Stoke City 35 players
- Manchester United – Stoke City 34 players
- Liverpool – Manchester United 19 players
Source: Wikidata (CC0), Wikipedia club articles and player infoboxes (years at each club). Youth spells and appearances that look unplayed are left out; volunteer-kept records can contain gaps or errors.