Premier League · former league club
- Leeds United 63 shared
- Leicester City 52 shared
- Everton 49 shared
- Wolves 48 shared
- Aston Villa 44 shared
- Crystal Palace 43 shared
- Manchester City 42 shared
- Southampton 34 shared
- Newcastle United 32 shared
- West Brom 32 shared
- Arsenal 31 shared
- Manchester United 30 shared
- West Ham United 25 shared
- Tottenham Hotspur 22 shared
- Liverpool 21 shared
- Chelsea 19 shared
- Huddersfield 57 shared
- Stoke City 54 shared
- Nottingham Forest 53 shared
- Watford 51 shared
- QPR 44 shared
- Middlesbrough 42 shared
- Fulham 39 shared
- Sunderland 37 shared
- Norwich City 37 shared
- Burnley 35 shared
- Brighton 35 shared
- Hull City 35 shared
- Coventry City 32 shared
- Brentford 32 shared
- Cardiff City 30 shared
- Reading 29 shared
- Luton Town 27 shared
- Rangers 24 shared
- Ipswich Town 24 shared
- Bournemouth 24 shared
- Wigan Athletic 22 shared
- Swansea City 22 shared
- Celtic 20 shared
- Le Havre 5 shared
- Feyenoord 4 shared
- AEK 4 shared
Famous players who played for Sheffield United
- Kyle Walker 2008–2009, 2009–2010
- Harry Maguire 2011–2014
- Phil Jagielka 2000–2007, 2019–2021
- Vinnie Jones 1990–1991
- Ian Rush 1998
- Gary Cahill 2007
- Dean Henderson 2018–2020
- Aaron Ramsdale 2015–2017, 2020–2021
- Alejandro Sabella 1978–1980
- Dominic Calvert-Lewin 2014–2016
- Gary Speed 2008–2010
- Kalvin Phillips 2026, 2026
- Ethan Ampadu 2020–2021
- Jack Rodwell 2020–2021
- Muhamed Bešić 2019–2020
- Martin Peters 1980–1981
- Steve Bruce 1998–1999
- Sam Vokes 2011
- Ciaran Clark 2022–2023
- Rob Holding 2025
- Tahith Chong 2026
- Ritchie De Laet 2010
- Conor Coady 2013–2014
- Phil Bardsley 2007–2008
- Traianos Dellas 1997–1999
- Herbert Chapman 1902–1903
- Mason Holgate 2024
- Sander Berge 2020–2023
- Iliman Ndiaye 2019–2023
- Harry Souttar 2024
- Adlène Guedioura 2021
- Jimmy Johnstone 1975–1977
- Sun Jihai 2008–2010
- Morgan Gibbs-White 2021–2022
- James Wilson 2018
- Tom Davies 2023–2024
- Oliver Burke 2020–2022
- Colin Kâzım-Richards 2006–2007
- Nathan Dyer 2008–2009
- Ahmed Fathy 2007
Source: Wikidata (CC0), Wikipedia club articles and player infoboxes (years at each club). Youth spells and appearances that look unplayed are left out; volunteer-kept records can contain gaps or errors.