Bundesliga
- Schalke 04 29 shared
- Eintracht Frankfurt 23 shared
- Borussia Dortmund 18 shared
- Bayern München 11 shared
- Beşiktaş 4 shared
- Nürnberg 23 shared
- Darmstadt 98 22 shared
- Bayer Leverkusen 21 shared
- Hamburger SV 20 shared
- Köln 18 shared
- Fortuna Düsseldorf 18 shared
- Hannover 96 18 shared
- Greuther Fürth 18 shared
- Stuttgart 18 shared
- VfL Bochum 18 shared
- Augsburg 17 shared
- Hertha BSC 16 shared
- Union Berlin 16 shared
- St. Pauli 14 shared
- Wolfsburg 14 shared
- Paderborn 13 shared
- Arminia Bielefeld 12 shared
- Borussia Mönchengladbach 12 shared
- Freiburg 11 shared
- Eintracht Braunschweig 10 shared
- Hoffenheim 9 shared
- Werder Bremen 8 shared
- Holstein Kiel 7 shared
- RB Leipzig 7 shared
- Ajax 6 shared
- Strasbourg 6 shared
- PSV 5 shared
- Heidenheim 5 shared
- Ingolstadt 5 shared
- Feyenoord 4 shared
- Metz 4 shared
- Saint-Étienne 4 shared
- Olympiakos 4 shared
- Espanyol 4 shared
- Fulham 4 shared
- Nantes 4 shared
Famous players who played for Mainz
- Shinji Okazaki 2013–2015
- Jürgen Klopp 1990–2001
- André Schürrle 2009–2011
- Nigel de Jong 2018
- Yoshinori Muto 2015–2018
- Bojan Krkić 2017
- Eric-Maxim Choupo-Moting 2011–2014
- Loris Karius 2012–2016
- Ivan Klasnić 2012–2013
- Neven Subotić 2006–2007, 2007–2008
- Ádám Szalai 2010, 2010–2013, 2019–2022
- Jean-Philippe Mateta 2018–2022
- Viktor Fischer 2017–2018
- Andreas Ivanschitz 2009–2011, 2011–2013
- Nadiem Amiri 2024–
- Silvan Widmer 2021–
- René Adler 2017–2019
- Gonzalo Jara 2014–2016
- Jonas Hofmann 2014–2015
- Christian Fuchs 2010–2011
- Andriy Voronin 2000–2003
- Mario Gavranović 2011–2012
- Taiwo Awoniyi 2019–2020
- Julian Baumgartlinger 2011–2016
- Abdou Diallo 2017–2018
- Filip Djuricic 2014–2015
- Ja-cheol Koo 2014–2015
- Eugen Polanski 2009–2010, 2010–2013
- Robin Quaison 2017–2021
- Jeffrey Bruma 2020
- Lewis Holtby 2010–2011
- Mohamed Zidan 2005–2006, 2007, 2012
- Emil Kostadinov 1998–1999
- Jae-sung Lee 2021–
- Jonas Lössl 2016–2018
- Stefan Posch 2026, 2026–
- Haji Wright 2019
- Dong-won Ji 2019–2021
- Ju-ho Park 2013–2015
- Manuel Friedrich 1998–2000, 2000–2002, 2004–2007
Source: Wikidata (CC0), Wikipedia club articles and player infoboxes (years at each club). Youth spells and appearances that look unplayed are left out; volunteer-kept records can contain gaps or errors.